The writing diary of a well-mellowed science writer who cares about the public understanding of science and knows the ropes. This blog bounces between my curiosity, the daily realities of professional writing, the joy of pursuing nature, and my recycling of ideas that won't be in some book or other as far as I can see, but still needed sharing. I welcome comments and suggestions! Spam will be blocked and reported. For my books, see http://members.ozemail.com.au/~macinnis/writing/index.htm
Search This Blog
Tuesday, 16 June 2015
This table is not for turning
Part of a table of logarithms.
In the mid-1200s, Alfonso X, Alfonso the Wise of Castile,
caused a set of astronomical tables that we now call the Alfonsine Tables, to
be published in Toledo, which is why they were sometimes also called 'Toledan
tables'. In 1620, a Swiss watchmaker, Joost Bürgi, published his Arithmetische und geometrische
Progress-Tabulen, a set of logarithmic tables, and in 1627, Johann Kepler
published a set of logarithms in the Tabulae
Rudolphinae, which commemorated his patron Rudolph II, Emperor of Austria,
and King of Bohemia.
Those examples aside, most tables in Europe up until that
time, and even for quite a long while after it, were tables that you could eat
at, or turn on an opponent when you played a game at them, or you could drink
people under them, but these were all tables with legs, and unless those sitting
at them were bent on a bit of graffiti work with their daggers, there would be
precious little recorded on them.
Yet at some point, the flat slab sort of table became, at
least for mathematicians, first and foremost a collection of figures, displayed
in a regular grid. We came to have contents tables, mathematical tables, data
tables and tabulation, and even the tab key on our computers, which had been
used in setting up tables on the typewriters that gave us our computer
keyboard. This then, is an exploration of tables and how they came to have
their modern meanings.
In the Middle Ages and before, the table was more than just
a place to eat: it was a place of great social occasion. Chaucer tells us that
the squire in the Canterbury Tales
was a fine young man:
Curteis he was, lowely, and servysable,
And carf biforn his fader at
Here, Chaucer reflects on the way that a table you sat at
for eating, and where you sat at it
in the Middle Ages, was also a sign of rank, a bit of a league table, you might
say. The fact that the squire sat at the same table as his father, the knight
of the Tales, and carved for him,
defines him as holding high rank. This follows a comment about the knight
himself, earlier in the General Prologue:
Ful often tyme he had the bord bigonne
Aboven alle nacions in Pruce
In other words, the knight sat at the head of the table, or
board, in Prussia, where knights of many nations gathered to help the Teutonic
Knights war against their heathen neighbours in Lithuania. So in Chaucer's
time, there was no real distinction between a board and a table, but there was
a distinction about where you sat at the table. This distinction is still
preserved today in places where honoured guests are seated at the High Table,
while other common folk are allocated positions below the salt.
In the Summoner's Tale, we hear of a friar who would beg for
A peyre of tables al of yvory,
And a poyntel polysshed fetisly,
And wroot the names alwey, as he stood,
Of alle folk that yaf him any good.
But once he was out of their sight,
He planed away the names everichon
That he biforn had written in
While these tables that the friar used were associated with
food in a way, they were small enough to carry around. In fact, they were
wax-coated ivory tablets, on which he scribed with a carefully pointed stylus
(the poyntel), but then as soon as he was out of sight, with a quick wipe, he
flattened the surface, ready to start a new sucker list on what the Romans
would have called a tabula rasa, a clean table.
The Romans were rather keen on
using tables to display things, and these were often slabs of marble, on which
important things were carved. Their Twelve Tables enshrined the basis of Roman
law, and when Cicero was a boy, he was required to learn these by heart. Moses
is usually depicted as coming off Mount Sinai with the Ten Commandments on two
tablets of stone.
So this type of table was often a tablet, more like the
'table book' that Nathaniel uses in Love's
Labours Lost than any item of furniture (or medication). We still call a
notepad a 'writing tablet' today, occasionally, but a table is more commonly a
flat slab with legs, used for sitting at, or perhaps it is used for a governing
council of some sort, though we still speak always of a board of directors,
even if they sit at a 'board table'. Documents drawn to the attention of those
present are tabled, meaning they are placed on an item of furniture.
Shakespeare uses both 'board' and 'table', in roughly equal
proportions to indicate an eating place, but he refers in his sonnets and
elsewhere to the tables of the heart, apparently meaning something like loving
memory, something that could be written on like a writing tablet, but this
leaves open the question of how we came to have other sorts of tables.
The original table was a flat slab or board, that might be
thrown across trestles to make the furniture sort of table, but they could also
be used to inscribe rules, laws and commandments, and both these meanings apply
to the Old English tabule, but the
mathematical use appears to come from astronomy. In the Franklin's Tale,
Chaucer writes of Aurelius bringing forth his "tables Tolletanes",
his Toledan astronomical tables, and Chaucer notes that they were "ful wel
corrected", so the tables were written on something correctable.
Could it be that astrologers and such carried these tables
around on slabs, or maybe even on wax-coated ivory tablets like those of the
Summoner? This was before the start of printing, and so it is at least
possible. After all, astronomers, long after that time, recorded their results
on planks of timber, which were sometimes, in some contexts, referred to as
tables, at least in a figurative sense. In 1390, John Gower wrote "He
broghte him sauf upon a table, Which to the lond him hath upbore",
describing somebody coming ashore from a shipwreck, clinging to a plank.
The other piece of evidence for this speculation that a
plank was used in place of paper comes from Urbain Leverrier, the French
astronomer, and his encounter in 1859 with an amateur called Lescarbault. This
man, who turned out just to be a poor observer who was mistaken, had apparently
detected a planet near the sun, the hypothetical planet Vulcan, and Leverrier
was keen to get Lescarbault's data, and define the orbit of the planet, but to
do that, he needed enough data to calculate the orbit, and that meant getting
all of the observations of black dots that Lescarbault had recorded.
This was at a time when paper was still quite expensive, and
sadly for Leverrier, the man's figures were all kept on a board, for lack of
paper, and he planed all the old figures off when he had no further use for
them. By then, 'tables of contents' were common, so perhaps we got the new use
from something like the 'times table' that might be displayed on a board in a
school room, though Charles Babbage published a Table of Logarithms in 1827.
There was also an 1826 paper that Babbage read to the Royal
Society about an engine "for the purpose of calculating tables and
impressing the results on plates of copper" — perhaps those copper plates
were tables? The term certainly dates back as far as 1805, so far as life
expectancies were concerned, because in that year, Joseph Banks urged the
famous Captain Bligh to become Governor of New South Wales, observing in
passing that Bligh's life was not yet over: 'I apprehend that you are about 55
years old — if so you have by the tables an expectation of 15 years' life'.
It probably matters little, for all those tables, logarithm,
trigonometric and even probability, have all been replaced by a calculator,
just as surely as the 'log tables' once replaced Napier's bones. If we did not
still have the periodic table and timetables to explain, we could probably let
the matter rest. Then again, maybe those are exactly the sort of tables that
can be displayed on a board.